New report for NHO Geneo: Norway's welfare problem is a shortage of people, not money
Norway spends more on welfare than almost any other country, yet a new report commissioned by NHO Geneo argues that the real constraint is no longer money. It is people.
The report, Et bærekraftig velferdssamfunn: Veivalg og muligheter ("A sustainable welfare society: choices and opportunities"), was written by Kåre Hagen, head of the Centre for Welfare and Labour Research (SVA) at OsloMet, and presented at NHO Geneo's annual conference. NHO Geneo is the employers' association for private health and welfare providers; Hagen writes in the foreword that he alone stands behind the analysis.
Three decades without progress on exclusion
Hagen's verdict on work inclusion is blunt. Measured by how many people get into stable work, rather than how many pass through programmes, results are weak: exclusion levels have not fallen in three decades — "snarere tvert om" (if anything the opposite).
- At the start of the 2000s Norway had one of Europe's highest employment rates. It is now in 7th place.
- Since 2001, when the first Inclusive Working Life agreement took effect, the employment rate for people aged 20–66 with a non-Norwegian background has risen only from 63 to 67%. For the rest of the population it has been practically flat: 79.8% in 2001, 79.3% in 2024.
- There are 105,000 young people under 30 outside work and education today.
- Half of Norway's disability pensioners say they struggled at school. "Young exclusion is very expensive," Hagen writes.
What a small improvement would be worth
Hagen does not attempt a full estimate of the societal cost of exclusion. Instead he shows how much even a marginal improvement is worth, citing a recent calculation (Andersen, 2026): a 10% reduction in sick leave and in the number of people on work assessment allowance (AAP) and disability benefit would save NOK 25 billion. If those people worked half-time on average instead of receiving benefits, it would add value equivalent to 35,000 full-time jobs.
Against that, he makes a rough guess that the public sector spends NOK 50–60 billion a year on inclusion services: about 24 billion through the Directorate of Integration and Diversity and 12 billion on NAV's labour market programmes, plus vocational rehabilitation, parts of addiction care, prison aftercare and municipal measures.
Flip the perspective
The core recommendation is to turn inclusion policy around. Today's system, Hagen argues, rests on three assumptions: that the person outside work is the problem to be fixed, that only ordinary jobs count, and that combining wages and benefits is a risk to be policed. Reversed, that becomes a programme:
- Place first, then train. People need to be inside work before they build the motivation and skills for it — the logic of supported employment.
- Design jobs that fit. Create real, productive roles for people who cannot do ordinary work, driven by employers' own interest. Municipalities short of care staff should move tasks from specialised personnel into jobs suited to people who struggle to get work.
- Make work plus benefits pay. Hagen proposes an experiment for people on AAP and disability benefit as large as the current youth tax-cut trial, for example letting a person give part of their benefit as a wage subsidy in return for the employer paying a set wage.
Sick leave as service quality
Hagen also treats sick leave in health and care as a quality and capacity issue. If every municipality had sick leave as low as the best 20%, health and care services would gain 10,800 full-time equivalents — without higher public spending. For 105,000 young people outside work and school, he floats a civilian alternative to military service, training them in crisis and preparedness work.
The report ends with 10 recommendations, from stronger pressure for innovation and better measurement of what works, to predictable conditions for private providers and a shift "from welfare state to welfare society".
Why it matters for employers: Hagen's argument puts employers at the centre. If Norway's labour shortage is to be solved from among those now outside work, inclusion has to happen in workplaces — through job design, support on the job and arrangements that make it worth it for both sides.
Read more on the fiscal cost of exclusion at InkludX Economics.
Source: Kåre Hagen (2026), Et bærekraftig velferdssamfunn: Veivalg og muligheter, report commissioned by NHO Geneo.